I bought the Seidio Swivel Hoster for the Treo 650 in 1/05 - loved it but it broke in the arch in 5/05. It was replaced by Seidio under the 6 month warranty, then in 12/05 it broke in the same spot but now not covered by warranty. Only 6 months from original purchase.

Had lunch with a Treo friend. Told him the story and he pulled out his Seidio Holster. He say this is his second in 8 months. His first broke within 6 months in the arch. Now his second is starting to crack too!